Censorship Debate
Censorship Debate
Be it resolved, what you call censorship, I call power struggle.
“You can have Rogan or Young. Not both.” So threatened Neil Young to Spotify in protest to the vaccine and COVID misinformation being spread on Joe Rogan’s incredibly popular and lucrative podcast. As more artists began to pull out from the platform, and users deleted their accounts, many decried what they viewed as the latest episode in an ongoing battle over control of the information landscape. Those claiming censorship argue that the Joe Rogan/Spotify episode, following in the footsteps of recent controversies such as Dave Chappelle’s Netflix special, is part of a worrisome trend reminiscent of authoritarian style information control that seeks to silence opinions of adversaries that deviate from the “accepted” mode of thought. The continuous effort to de-platform, ban, silence, or tarnish the views of others cannot be allowed to prevail in western democracies.
Others argue that this is not censorship, but rather legitimate protest: people using their money, art, voice, and agency to stand up against views they disagree with. In fact, they maintain, this type of protest should be championed as proof that democratic freedoms remain strong. Furthermore, demands of free speech are often aimed at protecting views which have negative impacts – views that should not be allowed to gain traction and influence audiences via massive platforms like Spotify or Netflix.
“This is a power struggle. Marginalized people are voicing their experiences in an effort to try to gain power, and those who have traditionally held power are looking to hold on to it.”
– KAREN ATTIAH
“Democracy requires tolerance for dissent. People need to be free to express themselves, to bring forth ideas, even provocative or offensive ideas. They need to be able to have conversations.”
– KAT ROSENFIELD
Pro
Con
You may also like

April 16, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: how the Liberals are benefiting from the Canada-US trade war

April 22, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: The Conservative Party’s failure to provide a roadmap for change

April 30, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: key takeaways from Canada’s election results

May 15, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: The Crisis of Canadian Democracy

May 26, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Carney’s bumpy start and Canada’s weaknesses exposed

June 3, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Mark Carney’s economic plan to get Canada back on track

June 9, 2025
– Listen
Munk Debates Podcast: Be it Resolved, this is America’s golden age

June 16, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Yossi Klein Halevi: why the West must support Israel’s war against Iran

July 3, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: how do you negotiate with Donald Trump?

July 10, 2025