Back to Navigation

Drug Legalization | Munk Debates

SEASON TWO - EPISODE #60

Drug Legalization

Be it resolved, legalize all drugs.

Guests
Nathaniel Erskine-Smith
Theodore Dalrymple

About this episode

2020 was a deadly year for North America’s substance abusers. Over 6,000 Canadians and 93,000 Americans died from opioid related deaths, a significant increase from 2019. And while cannabis recently became legal in Canada and parts of the US, many believe that the only way to solve the current crisis is by legalizing all drugs, especially opiates. Supporters say legalization will reduce crime, free up police resources, and generate millions in tax revenue that can be used to rehabilitate addicts instead of punishing them. Regulating drug sales would make them safer to administer and thus curb overdose rates. Legalization would also solve existing racial disparities in drug enforcement that unfairly target and imprison black men compared to their white counterparts. In a free society, they argue, adults should be free to do what they choose provided their actions are not causing harm to others.

Critics of legalization are raising red flags. Increasing access to drugs and normalizing their use will increase the abuse and addiction associated with these powerful opiates. We would see a substantial rise in consumption, the decay of our moral fabric, and a rise in health care costs needed to treat deadly addictions. And finally, critics point out, one need to look no further than America’s deadly opioid crisis to see that legalization will not curb addiction or death. Indeed, they argue, it will do just the opposite.

Share:

Guests

Nathaniel Erskine-Smith

“From drugs to sex work to assisted dying, there are so many different examples where when we push something underground, the problems get so much worse."

Nathaniel Erskine-Smith

“From drugs to sex work to assisted dying, there are so many different examples where when we push something underground, the problems get so much worse."

Nathaniel Erskine-Smith has been the Member of Parliament for Beaches-East York since 2015. Nate has always been in favour of pragmatic, evidence-based, and compassionate solutions to protect vulnerable people. He believes that the war on drugs has failed. Nate is a co-chair of the all-party cannabis caucus, and as a member of the Liberal caucus, Nate was one of the leading proponents of the legalization of marijuana and has introduced private members’ bills calling for the decriminalization or legalization of all drugs. It was partly on the basis of one of these private members’ bills that the Liberal government introduced Bill C-22, which would have ended a number of mandatory minimum sentences and allowed police officers more discretion when dealing with drug offenders. While Bill C-22 did not go as far as Nate would have liked, he will continue to be a strong voice in parliament, working across party lines on this important issue and to forge a consensus in the name of public health. In 2017, he appeared on an episode of Political Blind Date regarding cannabis legalization, with Conservative MP Garnett Genuis, and will be appearing in another upcoming episode of PBD in early 2022.

Theodore Dalrymple

“The current American opioid crisis started with perfectly legal prescription by incompetent, naïve, or corrupt doctors influenced by dishonest promotion.”

Theodore Dalrymple

“The current American opioid crisis started with perfectly legal prescription by incompetent, naïve, or corrupt doctors influenced by dishonest promotion.”

Theodore Dalrymple is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and a contributing editor of City Journal. He is a retired physician who, most recently, practiced in a British inner-city hospital and prison. Dalrymple has written a column for TheSpectator (London) for many years and writes regularly for National Review. Denis Dutton, editor of Arts & Letters Daily, called Dalrymple the “Orwell of our time.” 
 
Dalrymple is the author of An Intelligent Person’s Guide to Medicine (2001); Life at the Bottom: The Worldview That Makes the Underclass (2003); Romancing Opiates: Pharmacological Lies and the Addiction Bureaucracy (2006); coauthor of Is Old Europe Doomed? (2006); author of Our Culture, What’s Left of It: The Mandarins and the Masses (2007); In Praise of Prejudice: The Necessity of Preconceived Ideas (2007); Not With a Bang But a Whimper: The Politics and Culture of Decline (2010); The New Vichy Syndrome: Why European Intellectuals Surrender to Barbarism (2010); If Symptoms Persist (2010); Second Opinion: A Doctor’s Dispatches From The Inner City (2010); The Examined Life (2011); Litter: How Other People’s Rubbish Shapes Our Life (2011); Mr. Clarke’s Modest Proposal: Supportive Evidence from Yeovil (2011); Farewell Fear (2012); Anything Goes (2012); Spoilt Rotten: The Toxic Cult of Sentimentality (2012); The Policeman and the Brothel: A Victorian Murder (2012); The Pleasure of Thinking: A Journey through the Sideways Leaps of Ideas (2012); So Little Done: The Testament of a Serial Killer (2012); The Wilder Shores of Marx: Journeys in a Vanishing World (2012); Zanzibar to Timbuktu: A Journey Across Africa (2012); Monrovia Mon Amour: A Visit to Liberia (2012); and Admirable Evasions: How Psychology Undermines Morality (2015). 

Comments