Lockdowns Debate
Lockdowns Debate
Be it resolved, the reintroduction of shutdowns needs to be considered in U.S. states where COVID-19 infections are surging.
Over five million cases. More than 160,000 deaths, and counting. The U.S. currently leads the global tally for the highest number of COVID-19 cases. California, an early success story, has had to aggressively rollback the reopening of schools and business. Louisiana, Idaho, Texas, and Nevada are among dozens of states experiencing surging case counts, rising hospitalizations and increased deaths. Meanwhile some countries, originally devasted by the coronavirus, are reopening successfully, after driving new infections down to manageable levels. When public health policies, such as physical distancing, hand washing, masks, and increased testing, can’t bend the curve in new infections, some say the only way to prevent tens of thousands of more deaths is a second wave of shutdowns targeting the hardest hit areas. Critics say with shutdowns, the supposed “cure”, is worse than the disease. Millions will be denied essential medical treatment, including mental health. Jobs and businesses will be permanently lost. And, closed schools will prevent a much-needed return to normalcy for children and parents alike. Shutdowns are not the answer to the ongoing threat of COVID-19.
“The pandemic is boiling over in many locations in the United States and the most effective way to turn down the heat is to go into another shutdown.”
– Andrew Noymer
“A shutdown is a medieval measure. It’s the equivalent of cutting your arm because of some joint pain in your hand.”
– Dr. John Ionnidis
Pro
You may also like

July 29, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: The EU-US trade deal should serve as a warning to Canada and why supply management hurts the poorest Canadians

August 6, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: America’s checks and balances are failing to restrain Donald Trump

August 19, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: a phony peace deal for Ukraine could put all of Europe at risk

August 26, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: the US slides towards dictatorship and Carney clings to Canada’s peacemaking past

September 3, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: A public display of friendship between China, Russia, and India is a searing indictment of Trump’s foreign policy

September 10, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump is stuck in a dangerous spiral feedback loop and Rudyard and Andrew debate Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker program

September 24, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Carney’s Palestinian statehood recognition comes without conditions and the powerful companies benefiting from Trump’s authoritarianism

October 2, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump’s military speech ramblings should concern every Canadian

October 7, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump sends in the National Guard (again) and Mark Carney goes to Washington

October 16, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump’s Middle East diplomacy and why Canada should re-evaluate its auto sector subsidies

October 21, 2025