Schools and Grading Debate
Schools and Grading Debate
Be it resolved, schools that grade students are failing them.
It’s back to school for millions of students next week after a school year of unprecedented disruption and with the traditional grading systems and report card one of the main casualties. But some educators say this past year’s abandonment of letter grades and grade point averages has been a good thing and is key to reforming the education system. They say that for decades research has shown that traditional grading systems decrease student learning by shifting their attention from deep learning to how to play and win at the game of school. Giving out grades reduces student interest in knowledge for its own sake as well as the desire to take on challenges. Rather than providing a fair and helpful snapshot of a student’s progress, grades only succeed in capturing the inequity and bias that afflicts our education systems.
Supporters of traditional grading approaches respond that grades, especially when paired with individualized comments, provide a valuable feedback tool that is fundamental to a successful education system. Grades that are based on clearly defined learning goals address the problem of teacher bias and provide an honest answer to the key question on every student’s mind: how am I doing? Grades also communicate this important information to parents and to higher learning establishments with limited enrollment. Most importantly grades reward effort, a key pillar for a fair and just education system and the broader society it feeds.
Pro
Con
You may also like
October 6, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Canada’s separatist moment
November 4, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: what the blue tsunami means for the Canada-U.S. trade war
September 16, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Carney opens Canada for business and courts a new European alliance
October 28, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: A new generation is reshaping politics around the world
September 22, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Is Carney’s momentum pointing to a spring election?
October 5, 2026
– Watch
America’s Liberal Reckoning Debate
November 10, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump loses his grip on the GOP and Mark Carney opens the spending taps
October 21, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: France’s unrest and the West’s growth problem
October 13, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump’s gift to Putin and Alberta’s grievance referendum
August 28, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Is Canada prepared for the long fight?
September 29, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Is Mark Carney governing like a Conservative?
November 17, 2026