US Defense of Taiwan Debate
US Defense of Taiwan Debate
Be it Resolved, the United States should publicly pledge to defend Taiwan against Chinese aggression.
It’s no secret that both China and the US are preparing for war. Some American military experts think that an armed conflict between the two superpowers is inevitable and could begin as early as 2025. And while there is widespread agreement among Americans that the US should defend Taiwan from Chinese aggression, there is also widespread disagreement about whether the US government should make a public commitment to do so.
Some foreign policy experts argue that strategic ambiguity will signal that an invasion will be met by a weak response, thus bolstering China’s resolve to attack. Strategic clarity in the form of a pledge to defend Taiwan would intimidate Xi Jinping, deter his re-unification ambitions, and send a strong message of support to allies in the region. Other analysts say that a security guarantee by the US could force Xi’s hand and lead to a military conflict that would have otherwise remained hypothetical. The US should focus on deterring China from attacking Taiwan without resorting to military commitments that could spiral into a long, protracted and devastating war with a rising superpower.
Arguing for the motion is David Sacks. He’s a Research Fellow at Council on Foreign Relations, where he specializes in U.S.-China relations.
Arguing against the motion is Michael Mazarr, a senior political scientist at the RAND Corporation. He previously served as a special assistant to the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
“We have to reckon with a much more assertive, aggressive China under Xi Jinping… our policy of strategic ambiguity will not serve us well in the coming decades”
-DAVID SACKS
“This would be an incredibly destructive war. There’s a roster of steps other than public clarity that would be the best way to keep this conflict from falling into that disaster.”
-MICHAEL MAZARR
Pro
You may also like
February 12, 2025
– Listen
Munk Debate Podcast: Gaza, tariffs, and a constitutional showdown
February 28, 2025
– Listen
Munk Debates Podcast: Stephen Walt and Evelyn Farkas on Trump’s plan for Ukraine and the changing world order
March 7, 2025
– Listen
Munk Debates Podcast: Trump’s trade wars with Jared Bernstein and Oren Cass
March 18, 2025
– Listen
Munk Debates Podcast: Mahmoud Khalil, Democrats in disarray, and can tariffs actually benefit the working class?
April 3, 2025
– Listen
Munk Debates Podcast: Tension with Iran, Greenland annexation, and Chinese aggression against Taiwan
May 29, 2024
– Watch
Munk Debate on Trump’s America
April 16, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: how the Liberals are benefiting from the Canada-US trade war
April 22, 2025
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: The Conservative Party’s failure to provide a roadmap for change
April 30, 2025
