Surging COVID-19 Debate
Surging COVID-19 Debate
Be it resolved, the public health response to COVID-19 should focus on protecting the old and letting the young get on with living normal lives.
We’re heading into the twelfth month of a global pandemic and in many places the spread of COVID-19 shows no signs of slowing down. As infections continue to surge, countries in the northern hemisphere have started to reimpose lockdowns restricting people’s movement and social interactions and closing portions of their economies. Many political leaders and their public health advisors argue that these kinds of restrictions are necessary as a crisis measure when infections spiral out of control, threatening a collapse of hospitals and devastating health consequences. They also advocate a strategy of suppression to keep infections low once the crisis is brought under control. But some politicians and public health experts are criticizing what they believe is an overly draconian approach. They say that it makes no sense to prevent the healthy and young from going about their normal lives when their risk of dying from the virus is less than the flu and they suffer considerable collateral damage from lockdowns. They argue that countries should adopt a focused approach to fighting the pandemic that zeroes in on protecting elderly and vulnerable.
“With COVID-19 there’s a thousand-fold difference in mortality between the oldest and the youngest. That’s something we have to utilize as we fight this enemy.”
– Martin Kulldorff
“To send out many millions of young people who’ve made such sacrifices to keep the pandemic under control and expose them to a disease where we don’t know the consequences is absolutely unethical, quite apart from ineffective.”
– Stephen Reicher
Pro
Con
You may also like
July 31, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Canada’s two competing priorities and the new U.S. Fed Chair signals compliance with Trump
August 21, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: how far is Carney willing to bend for Trump?
July 10, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: the Iran-U.S. ceasefire unravels and Alberta pulls ahead while Ontario and Quebec fall behind
August 7, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Carney considers concessions to Trump as U.S. Power wanes abroad
September 16, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Carney opens Canada for business and courts a new European alliance
August 14, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: the Canada-US trade deadline looms and Iran calls Trump’s bluff
June 23, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump loses his bargaining power and has Mark Carney’s “elbows up” promise delivered?
July 17, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump undermines his own party and the crisis of Canadian conservatism
July 3, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: the American experiment at 250 and Canada’s pipeline gamble
August 28, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Is Canada prepared for the long fight?
July 24, 2026
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Andrew Coyne: Trump doubles down on the Iran war and tariffs, and an AI model escapes the lab
August 25, 2026