Unions Debate
Unions Debate
Be it resolved, workers of the world, unite!
Unions are making a comeback. Frustrated with pay, benefits, job security, and working conditions, Amazon workers in Staten Island and Starbucks employees across New York have opted to join unions and initiate collective bargaining with their employers, inspiring a wave of pro-union discussions and meetings among big retail workers across Canada and the US. Many believe that America’s dwindling union membership – down to 11.2% of the workforce compared a near 30% high in the 1950’s – is to blame for rising income inequality and wage stagnation. Organized labour, they argue, is an important tool in fighting corporate influence. They also strengthen workers’ rights, increase private and public sector employee bargaining power, and prevent companies from making low-income jobs obsolete via automation or offshore employment. In short, fewer unions mean lower pay for everybody.
Other economists argue that unions are not the answer to our current economic woes. Organized labour, they maintain, inflates the wages of a privilege few, while reducing economic output by tying job security and pay to seniority instead of productivity and skill, thereby punishing high-value workers. The 21st century, rather, demands a workforce that champions flexibility, individual bargaining power, and risk-taking on behalf of its workers. The answer to income inequality is to do away with unions and put more power back into the hand of the individual worker.
“Unions reduce the wage suppressing effects of corporate power by providing countervailing power to workers”
– HEIDI SHIERHOLZ
“Inequality is exacerbated by unions. And the reason people move to non-union states is because they get better jobs and they don’t have to pay union dues.”
– ARTHUR LAFFER
Speakers
You may also like
January 30, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with David Horovitz
February 7, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with John Mearsheimer
February 12, 2024
– Listen
UNRWA Debate
February 22, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Sarah Paine
February 27, 2024
– Listen
Joe Biden Debate
March 6, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Gilead Sher
March 13, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Rose Gottemoeller
March 19, 2024
– Listen
Donald Trump Debate
March 28, 2024
– Listen
Bidenomics Debate
April 3, 2024
– Listen
TikTok Debate
April 9, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Dr. Richard Haass
April 15, 2024
