COVID-19 Restrictions Debate
COVID-19 Restrictions Debate
Be it resolved, COVID-19 is everywhere, it’s time to lift all restrictions for good.
It’s been almost two years since COVID-19 was first declared a pandemic, and yet every few months a new variant emerges, sweeping through entire populations and thwarting any plans for a return to pre-COVID normal life. While many governments are still using lockdowns, mask mandates, online school and business closures in order to blunt the surges and prevent a health care collapse, some countries like England and Denmark are pivoting away from these measures, aiming to treat COVID as we do other common infectious pathogens: no restrictions, no mandates, no closures. Governments and health experts supporting this approach argue that safe and effective vaccines and treatments will protect the majority of infected people from severe illness and death. Online learning is detrimental to the mental health of children, exacerbates inequality, and keeps parents out of the workforce. Governments finances are at the breaking point having had to repeatedly bailing out businesses. And finally, humans are social creatures. We cannot continue to prioritize the health of a vulnerable few over the mental and physical wellbeing of entire populations.
Many in healthcare and public health do not agree. Yes, COVID is not as dangerous a threat as was originally, but record case counts lead to widespread staff shortages and hospital overcapacity. Letting a virus run rampant is an irresponsible health care approach that will lead to more disease, deaths, and highly transmissible variants. Previous measures like masking and closures have curbed the rapid spread of COVID, and when and if necessary, governments should not hesitate to introduce them again.
“We have put in place lockdowns and other measures to try to control the spread of the virus with really no endpoint in sight, permanently altering the way we live in pursuit of a futile goal.”
– JAY BHATTACHARYA
“We need to be sensible. Do things when there are surges, protect everyone, including the elderly, when we’re at higher risk, and then yes, when case numbers decrease, we can relax.”
– JEREMY FAUST
Speakers
Pro
Con
You may also like
February 12, 2024
– Listen
UNRWA Debate
February 22, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Sarah Paine
February 27, 2024
– Listen
Joe Biden Debate
March 6, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Gilead Sher
March 13, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Rose Gottemoeller
March 19, 2024
– Listen
Donald Trump Debate
March 28, 2024
– Listen
Bidenomics Debate
April 3, 2024
– Listen
TikTok Debate
April 9, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Dr. Richard Haass
April 15, 2024
– Listen
Munk Dialogue with Gregg Carlstrom
June 17, 2024
– Watch
Munk Debate on Anti-Zionism
April 23, 2024
