test Ceasefire-Hostage Deal Debate - Munk Debates

Ceasefire-Hostage Deal Debate

September 12, 2024
00:00:00
00:00:00

Ceasefire-Hostage Deal Debate

Be it Resolved, Israel must agree to a hostage deal

Following the execution of six Israeli hostages in Gaza, Israeli protesters are demanding Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu agree to a cease-fire deal that would guarantee the release of the remaining hostages. The deal on the table, however, would force Israel to concede to Hamas’s central demand: that the IDF withdraw from the Philadlphi Corridor which separates Gaza from Egypt. Those calling for a ceasefire argue that saving the remaining hostages should be the highest priority for Israel, which can always re-occupy the corridor in the future should it present another security risk. Others argue that Benjamin Netanyahu is right and any deal that allows Hamas to retake this essential strip – whose tunnels operate as the supply line for weapons being smuggled into Gaza – presents a major security risk that Israel cannot tolerate. Striking a deal now will allow Hamas to recapture Gaza and guarantee that this war, which has cost too many lives on both sides of the border, will soon have to be fought again.

Arguing in favour of the resolution is Barak Medina, a Professor of Human Rights Law at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Arguing against the resolution is Gadi Taub. He’s an Israeli historian, author, political commentator, and co-host of the popular Tablet Magazine podcast, Israel Update.

“Sacrificing 3000 people in the future for 200 now is not a moral calculus that I’m willing to sign on.”

– GADI TAUB

“If we take the position of just giving up on the hostages, we risk the future of the state of Israel.”

– BARAK MEDINA

Share

Vote

Join to vote
21% 79%
00:00:00
00:00:00